Hmmm...I wonder if we teachers should think of ourselves more as coaches of the Game of Life. Maybe this will help us incorporate or diversify our differentiation techniques. Never having been part of a sports team, because I suck at sports, I never thought of coaches as being great differentiators. Thinking about it though, it does seem natural because you can't have half your team sitting out because they are not getting the point of the game.The point I remember most from all of this is backward design. I've been in a class now for one and a half weeks with the same amount of time to go. The teacher (very thoughtfully) carefully laid out three week's worth of lesson plans for me. What I was unable to find, was the ultimate goal for the students during my three weeks' time with them and the lessons were not making sense to me. They were out of context. She also might not have considered the fact that, even with a guest teacher the students are familiar with, there will be (are!) management issues that sometimes hold the kids back and lessons will have to be reinforced (read: re-taught). Is this where the coaching comes in? Couple this with the fact that I can't see a connection between the lessons I'm giving and the independent math work stations the students are doing. Also, these math lessons are very scripted giving the teacher little wiggle room for presentation and with such a strict schedule that the writers (and
![]() |
| Math |
So, what to do? I look to the end of the unit, figure out where I'm going and try to teach to that (whew! Alliteration!). When I figured out where the goal was, I had a better idea of how to get there (though I still don't see the connection between lessons and stations...).
With this in mind, I really connected to McTighe's idea of What is the ultimate goal of school? To paraphrase Thomas Jefferson, if children are uneducated, it will cost us in the long run. He hit the nail on the head. Bear with me... I think in terms of backward design when educating my boys. When I say educating, I mean more than subjects taught in school. I teach them everything from monetary responsibility to the consequences of kindness without cause. My ultimate goal, of course, is to mold them into awesome men that are productive and contribute to their society - hopefully the goal of all parents and teachers for all the children they come in contact with. And we bring this goal all the way down through school to kindergarten in teaching them cooperation and not to yell or hit each other: The ultimate backward design.
backward designing all the way up from high school or beyond.

I think you synthesized the ideas really well and focused on a good perspective focusing point and that is about answering the question, "What is the point of all of this?" You are absolutely right. I think your perspective on trying to teach a unit out of context was interesting. UBD is really intuitive if you think about it. Without at least a glimpse of the big picture, it would be very disorienting for teachers and students alike. I'm beginning to think that differentiation is not effectively possible without some element of UBD thinking.
ReplyDeleteEric
Debbie-- I totally get what you're saying about being a guest teacher. I'm constantly wondering where these teachers get these lessons from?!?! What you said about being a Coach in the Game of Life is definitely true. However, it's often easy for me to get in a rut of thinking....well, I only have these students for a day, what can I really do for them in that short time? Likewise, I'm sure some teacher think that way, too. "I only have them for a year...what's really possible anyway?" And, then, more students fall through the cracks...
ReplyDeleteAlso, all this talk of looking backward sort of reminds me of the Common Core? I'm thinking they started at the end result and then worked backwards--is this true? Maybe I just heard that somewhere and made it up... :)
Hi Debbie
ReplyDeleteI really think that being a guest teacher would be really tough and you would only see snapshoots and never a photo album. You have always been teaching with context if I am correct. You began this semester telling us about working with your kids on units that area wrapped around good things. UBD and DI are besties and that is apparent in your ability to come up creative activities to teach your kids about this and that at home.